why don’t you BOTH SHUT UP?!?
i just finished watching shut up, little man, a documentary about two drunk men who argued loudly and the two young men who secretly recorded them & circulated the tapes. i have a few thoughts:
1) the movie is 89 minutes long. that might have been overly ambitious. at 45 minutes, i was saying, “i think we’re good, right?”
2) i will admit to a touch of voyeurism, but the idea of recording someone’s private conversations - and LAUGHING at them - upsets me on a deep level. when i was 19, i dated a young man who shared a house with two other guys. one night the boyfriend played me a tape (this was ‘91-‘92 - around the same time as the “shut up” phenomenon) of one of his roommate’s post-coital conversations with a one night stand, recorded from outside his closed bedroom door. as boyfriend cracked up, my blood ran cold; it was disturbing and unsettling. i’ve never forgotten that feeling. so i’m sorry if i don’t get the joke.
3) back in 1995, two different guys (not even the OG dudes) tracked down peter, the originator of the “shut up, little man!” line. they were both trying to get his story, either for a movie or for a written piece. the meeting was videotaped. when that videotaped clip was shown to the various talking heads/super fans, the fans didn’t seem to like it. it wasn’t the same, they said. it was too real. only then did they seem to realize that they had been fetishizing a couple of PEOPLE, people with actual problems, problems that possibly led to their weird existence of living together in a seedy apartment, drinking and fighting.
4) also, quit twisting yourselves into knots trying to justify your “art,” fellas.
5) after seeing so many other attempts at capitalizing on these recordings flounder & fail, this documentary feels like a last-ditch effort to lock in a legacy.
6) wow, that last thought was extremely cynical, even for me. i’m going to bed.








